Tuesday 7 May 2019

Literature and Spirituality - ELSA MEET 28 April 2019



ELSA MEET
28 April 2019
Goverdhan Hotel, Agra, India




“Why is there so much disturbance, so much fighting and quarrelling in the name of God? There has been more bloodshed in the name of God than for any other cause, because people never went to the fountain-head; they were content only to give a mental assent to the customs of their forefathers, and wanted others to do the same. What right has a man to say he has a soul if he does not feel it, or that there is a God if he does not see Him? If there is a God we must see Him, if there is a soul we must perceive it; otherwise it is better not to believe. It is better to be an outspoken atheist than a hypocrite.” ― Swami Vivekananda, Raja Yoga


Literature and Spirituality

In his opening remarks, Professor Nibir Ghosh mentioned, to the ovation of participants present, the views on the topic shared online by distinguished members namely, Tulip Chowdhury from Amherst, Massachusetts, USA,  Dr. Margarita Merino, Spanish poet based in USA, Dr. Arati Biswal from Bhubaneshwar, Dr. Manju from Chandigarh, among others.

This was followed by Mr. Mohit Mahajan who asked some intriguing questions about the literature that can be considered as Spiritual. He also pondered over whether spirituality can actually exist outside religious texts like the Ramayana and Mahabharata. Prof Ghosh tried to allay Mr. Mohit’s doubts by quoting the words of Emily Dickenson: “Prayer is the little implement through which people reach/ Where Presence—is denied them.” Mr. Surinder Sabharwal explained that the spirituality’s search of existence is beyond comprehension. Dr. Anjali Singh carried on the discussion by highlighting the historical existence of spirituality in literature from the times when moral plays were enacted in churches. She talked about the metaphysical poets who had integrated the spiritual discourse in their poems.

Mr. Rajeev Khandelwal explained how deeply one’s spiritual beliefs influences the writing of any poet. He said that most of the time, unknowingly or knowingly, a person’s thinking is guided by his spirituality. Saurabh Agarwal talked about the influence of Bhagwat Gita in the poetry of Walt Wittman. He also explained how a simple line or a word is enough to provide a spiritual experience to someone who is adequately touched by it.   Dr. Shipra Kulshreshta cited the poems, “A Psalm of Life” by H. W. Longfellow and “Second Coming” by W. B. Yeats. She highlighted the spiritual messages hidden in these poems. Dr Sanjay Mishra emphasised on doing away with making spirituality a fashion. He tried to distinguish spirituality from intellectualism. According to him works of Sri Aurobindo Ghosh qualify as spiritual literature. He also mentioned W.B. Yeats poem “The Lake Isle of Innisfree.” Dr. D. K. Singh talked about Milton’s poem “On His Blindness” and William Blake’s poem. “The Tiger” by William Blake with regard to elements of spirituality.    

Dr. Ghosh concluded the meet by referring to three seminal texts, Milton’s Paradise Lost, George Bernard Shaw’s Saint Joan and Hermann Hesse’s Siddhartha. In the light of Samuel Huntington’s thesis in The Clash of Civilizations, Dr. Ghosh underlined the significance of these texts in showing how a rational approach to religion and scriptures can be a beacon light in these contemporary times of cultural fundamentalism.

Spirituality and Literature
Tulip Chowdhury
Literature and spirituality weave tapestries of human lives. Literature is attached to life like a spider’s web, spirituality in the middle supports the mysteries of creation. All living things emerge from the invisible world, unseen until they manifest into physical beings. And together they are entwined like ivies on a tree. In the one-way journey from birth to end, they keep us tangled at every step.
As we try to make sense of our days, search for the meaning of life, at times we seem to be like puppets of our spiritual world. The reasons we are sent to the world and our purpose in living the life that we do. Our materialistic world is like a distraction that consistently dazzles our senses and leads us on to endless quests of success, and we seldom are satisfied with our achievements. The satisfaction of one want calls in for a new one, the social ladders keep going higher and higher, and within us roams a monstrous hunger to make permanence of our pre-destined hours on the Earth.
When we pause on our life-tracks and connect to the source of life, calmness unites us all. The universe, life, visible and the invisible world become one truth: to appreciate and love life. And love is never demanding, it is gentle care of those who are around us. Generosity, stemming from love is about sharing what we have, it can be a kind word or a glass of water handed to a thirsty being. There is no need to wait for wealth or power to be good, the present moment and trying for each part to make it the best is what matters. Spirituality is like the roots of living, it brings freedom to our inner being.

“Mirrors” to Reflect Upon for the Community of the Humanities:
Recalling the "Golden Century" of Spain and World Literature
                                        Margarita Merino de Lindsay
As a model and a mirror, I think often of that period of the Seventeenth Century in which Spanish society was in economic recession and decline, overwhelmed with conflicts, poverty, wars and pestilence.  It redeemed itself for posterity through the genius of its artists and writers.  Painters and writers from the Golden Century lit the flame of their passion, lighting still our days with their talents and trades. They created masterpieces, works able to penetrate the complexity of their whole epoch. Its contradictions and confrontations, its vivid use of imagination, its philosophies and fears, its horrors and wonders, its powerful dynamics whose tensions were giving birth to a complex, poignant art, which profoundly captured the chiaroscuro of its soul that was never demonstrated in any other place on earth as it was in Spain.  The Spaniards express themselves more freely in the Baroque.  In the forceful manner of presenting their subjects, those artists bring to us the spirit of their country that goes deep to austere severity. They were the pride of their patrons, the kings of Spain.  The idea of Felipe II for the Escorial project was "Nobility without arrogance, majesty without ostentation." The Spanish artists showed an almost physical encounter with supernatural love in their intimate perspective on their God -- who was also the God of every tiny creature, because all things in the Baroque got a space and a soul.
The Golden Century (which does not fit within the XVI or XVII centuries but overlaps both) goes from the new sentimentality of Garcilaso de la Vega and his renaissance connections with the Latin classical tradition, to the passionate temblor of San Juan de la Cruz and his genuine mysticism which expresses the psychology of an individual modern feeling which remains so contemporary; from the intellectual wish of perfection and rise, the pain of the alienated from Fray Luis de León; the cool temper and freedom of Teresa de Ávila, an imaginative, brave, hard worker and smart woman who was able to manage well her talents of foundation; the great lyrical theater of Lope de Vega where every member of the audience felt involved because the vibrant humanity and spontaneity that made it so popular; from Góngora's superb culteranismo plenty of erudition and technical skill in its shape, to the intellectual conceptismo of Francisco de Quevedo and his variations of themes, obsessions and approaches, from the sometimes burlesque, sardonic and iconoclastic to the obscene or eschatological, but deeply serious and moralistic too in his intense melancholy of love and exploration of death, decay and fugacity in his disillusionment hold in stoicism where always passion persists.
The finest painters such as El Greco, Ribera, Velázquez, Zurbarán, Murillo or Valdés Leal, define the variety of approaches from the Baroque. The last two represent the extreme contrasts between colorful sweetness and the emotional pathos and dramatic effect that best define the late baroque artist.  But although these masterpieces are Baroque, not all of them are immersed in the spirit of Counter-Reformation, which spiritually wanted to shake the entire society moving the spectators of such marvelous art to awaken their consciences. The allegory of human fragility trespassed upon profound ethics or deep religious beliefs and the feeling of general discouragement in the badly managed country under the minor Austrias.
As Valdés Leal, Francisco de Quevedo o Mateo Alemán did reflecting about vanitas, with compelling emotion too, the corruption of the human body and the corruption of society can be used to purify and obtain a better condition. The disturbing message of Valdés Leal in his famous "Hieroglyphs of our last days" (composed by the two pictures called "In ictu oculi" and "Finis gloria mundi") also known as "The triumph of death" was one of repentance for salvation, understanding it with the obvious differences and logical connotations we must attach to put them in our context. But in comparison and contrast with the Spanish late Baroque this society in which we live, mostly controlled under the power of conservative thought, the attitude is much more conformist because it does not look for any aesthetics of extreme beauty or moving perfection to urge its members to have an epiphany.  It seems the empire of goods is enough for too many citizens who belong to the abundance of society and who forget about sacrifice, compassion and life changing events in the perspective of fugacity when at the end we will be forced to abandon every possession. … Again the convulsive Spanish society where the Baroque Art was happening is in my opinion a mirror for reflecting.  A great part of it expressed the Roman Catholic thought of the moment, and that art was following the directions of the Counter-Reformation and the Council of Trent (1545-1563), whose goals were to improve the religious consciousness.  The ideal was to use the principles of Truth, Goodness, Beauty, and to accomplish the acts of mercy (las obras de misericordia) to obtain salvation--inspiring all educated members of society who could afford to be involved in charity and compassion as a way to elevate the whole of society in a spirituality that was able to bring consolation as well.  This is very clear in Sevilla, Andalucía, in the times of Miguel de Mañara and the church of La Hermandad de la Caridad, an excellent example to learn the spirit of those old times where the epidemics of bubonic pestilences spread a horribly high mortality.
My exploration of the Golden Century of Spain confirms that its message of endurance still is so valid even in this, the twenty-first century.  It is of no matter if it comes from reminiscences of Medieval, Renaissance or Baroque, it is alive in pictures and pages more educational than our contemporary artifacts and remakes. If I am bringing today the remembrance of past ideals, as this one that put together las armas y las letras (weapons and letters), it is because it is needed now more than ever.  Symbolic weapons such as those of untiring logic, vigorous erudition, applied talent, convincing intelligence and knowledge thoroughly prepared, are asking all of us who share the passion to believe that education is the most accurate and powerful tool to transform society, if we are brave enough to move it higher by fighting against the army of confusion, materialism and mediocrity, lack of understanding or respect. 

Nature and Spirituality in Thoreau's Walden
Arati Biswal
Henry David Thoreau, 19th Century New England thinker, writer, poet, naturalist and American transcendentalist, retreated from society to live in nature. From 1845-47 Thoreau lived in a small cabin he built himself on the shore of Walden Pond, a mile and a half south of Concord in Massachusetts. This account of his experiment of twenty-six months of a life of simplicity in the midst of nature is put forth in his book Walden.
Walden Pond, at the edge of which he lived, symbolizes the spiritual significance of nature. The book celebrates the unity of nature, humanity and divinity, a central idea of transcendentalism. According to Thoreau's transcendentalist philosophy, nature, man and God are unified. Thoreau's life at Walden Pond is represented as ideal for enjoying that unity. He termed his praxis as self- culture or cultivation of the soul, an aspiration to live a philosophical or spiritual life. This spiritual exercise as put forth in Walden included contemplation, solitude, walks in nature, reading, journal writing, conversation and above all, simple living.
In Chapter 2 of Walden, "Where I Lived, and What I Lived for," Thoreau says that he went to the woods "to front only the essential facts of life" and that he "did not wish to live what was not life, living is so dear." He wanted to experience life to its fullest and live "Spartan-like" to discover the sublimity of life. He believed that "our life is frittered away by detail" and exhorts, "Simplicity, Simplicity, Simplicity!" Like ants, man keeps himself busy all the time. This concentrated effort at improving material wealth however does not lead to wellbeing or happiness.
Thoreau's sentiments in Walden are both a recommendation for living life as well as reflecting on life's true meaning. By this, both people and nation would turn to an elevated purpose and men would not fail to live life worthily. Thoreau underlines the negative impact of the railroad, "We do not ride on the railroad; it rides upon us." The same holds true of modern technology that has hijacked our lives. By turning to nature and observing it, human beings can experience their own unity with God. He goes to the woods to live "deliberately." He reveled in "innocence with Nature herself." Thoreau expresses his faith in simplicity as the path to spiritual wakefulness. By emulating nature and being in harmony with it, man can awaken to profound possibilities of everyday life. Speaking of his morning experience he remarks, "Then there is least somnolence in us; and for an hour, at least, some part of us awakens which slumbers all the rest of the day and night...we are...awakened by our Genius." This is an echo of the idea of "Brahma Muhurta," central to Indian spiritual thought, an ideal time for meditation, spiritual practices and for attaining supreme knowledge. In Walden, there are other overt references to the Bhagvad-Gita and other sacred Indian texts.
Thoreau's spirituality consisted in cultivating awareness, transcending the ego, identifying with nature and reanimating the conscience. This would bring personal and social transformation. He vied for a life that shunned superficiality. He was influenced by the teachings of the Bhagvad Gita that instruct to meditate on the soul "atman."  Thus, according to Thoreau, life is exploration of personal and spiritual growth for which a simple life in Nature is essential.

Ardhhnarishwar - The Half Woman: Re-Reading of Gender Roles in
Mahesh Dattani’s Dance Like a Man

Manju

Religion and literature have always been inseparable components of each other specially in India where literature revolves around religion and religion expands through literature. Hinduism is the oldest Indian religion. This term doesn't refer to any God; rather it first refers to a place and then to people. S. Radhakrishnan has addressed religion as "museum of beliefs." Literature derives its life from society which gets inspiration from the mythical figures discussed in religious literature. A flawless man is often identified with Purushottam Rama and a flawless woman is also identified either with Annapurna, Laxmi or Sita. There are certain mythological figures which are identified with the third gender which is mocked at in the same society. India is often considered a conservative country regarding gender roles. Social behavior is fixed on the basis of sex and gender. A man behaving like a woman and a woman behaving like a man is unacceptable in the society. Either they are rejected or they are humiliated and this makes their lives pathetic as it happens in the play Dance Like a Man by Mahesh Dattani. Jairaj, who is interested in making his career in dance, is rejected by his own father as dance is considered a woman's territory. Although dancing image of Natraj is adorned with reverence while dancing men like Jairaj are humiliated. Ardhhnarishwar is admired but ironically third genders are abominated. True religion gives freedom to the people to behave the way they want and this may be the reason why Lord Shiva who is known for his manhood as the phallus of the deity is worshipped, is known for his half-woman form. According to Shivpurana, a religious book, the deity comes on the earth in the feminine form multiple times like once he comes as a midwife to help one of his devotees and as a gopi to enjoy Krishna's raasleela where no other man than Krishna was allowed. These are the instances which prove that there was space for all the genders in ancient Hinduism and it needs contemplation.


Spirituality and Literature
Sanjay Mishra

The fact of the matter is this that whatever is being said here on this subject amounts to academic and intellectual exercise whereas, in my view which may be erroneous, spirituality is not an academic or intellectual thing; it is a matter of experience.  
It is also important to separate spirituality and faith or religion. As it happens, the discussion on spirituality is inextricably tied to religion and most of the interventions on spirituality tend to get mired in the maze of religious conundrums. To my mind, the world of spiritual experience and understanding is over and above the sublunary separations and categorizations of  mankind.  In the spiritual universe, all humanity is one: there are no divisions and no borders between people all across the globe.
As a student of literature one comes across terms and concepts like spirituality and mysticism when one deals with the writings of Wordsworth, Emerson, Thoreau, Whitman, Yeats and the like. But frankly speaking, the talk of spirituality, mysticism, etc. is not convincing. It goes over and above one’s head. For the sake of intellectual discussion, one tends to explain the meanings and interpretations which exist in books and academic discourses about the spiritual connotations in writings of such writers; but it all does not make much sense to a person with a rational bent of mind. These things touch and exist in the realm of experience, soul, spirit and enlightenment.
Nonetheless, I have marveled at ideas and expressions such as “undisturbed delight” (Wordsworth’s The Prelude), “To me the meanest flower that blows can give/Thoughts that do often lie too deep for tears” (‘Immortality Ode’), “Teach me half the gladness/That thy brain must know,/Such harmonious madness/From my lips would flow/The world should listen then, as I am listening now” (Shelley’s ‘To a Skylark’) and spiritual dimensions of Whitman’s Leaves of Grass. Reading all such ethereal and esoteric stuff makes one feel like saying along with the Bard of Avon: “There are more things in heaven and earth, Horatio, /than are dreamt of in your philosophy” (Shakespeare’s Hamlet).
I am very passionate about D.H. Lawrence and his writings and the philosophy of the religion of blood as revealed in his novels. Lawrence disliked didactic morality in art and literature and his works led to extremely heated debates and battles, both intellectual and legal. It is really fascinating to see Lawrence as the most spiritually awakened fiction writer, as has been suggested by many, because his kind of philosophy of human relations and experience is possible only when one has spiritual insights.


Here in India, one finds the personality and creativity of Sri Aurobindo to be exhibiting in the highest degree and synchronicity the merger of spirituality and literature. He was a poet and a seer non-pareil. His poetry, critical commentaries on English poetry and later his journey to spirituality via politics and setting up of the ashram in Pondicherry are extraordinary and visionary.  

Literature & Spirituality

Rajiv Khandelwal

It would be difficult to speak on the topic “Literature & Spirituality” without a look to understand what is meant by Spirituality. Cambridge dictionary defines Spirituality as the quality that involves deep feelings and beliefs of a religious nature, rather than the physical parts of life. Some define Spirituality as the quality of being concerned with the human spirit or soul as opposed to material or physical things. Spirituality is an internal sanctuary, free of the rules and expectations of the physical world. Some say that spirituality exists within a unique, unbreakable relationship between the heart and the mind. It is an internal harmony that allows one to endure the most harrowing of circumstances and yet enables its host to continue to offer compassion to others.

Spirituality recognizes that our role in life has a greater value than what we do every day. It can relieve us from dependence on material things and helps us to understand our life’s greater purpose. Spirituality can also be used as a way of coping with change or uncertainty. I, personally, prefer a definition Oprah floated that Spirituality is the measure of how willing we are to allow some power greater than ourselves—to enter our lives and guide us along our way.

And I interpret this as an event that can connect with the deep inside of one’s sel. Now this state will differ from one person to another. The plot, scene, a sentence, metaphor, image or symbol, from drama, poetry or novel – Fictional or factual – may move one’s heart, but it may not effect another person in the same way. For example, let us look at a selection from Hermann Hesse's Siddhartha - The Ferryman (Part 4):

And once again, when the river had just increased its flow in the rainy season and made a powerful noise, then said Siddhartha: "Isn't it so, oh friend, the river has many voices, very many voices? Hasn't it the voice of a king, and of a warrior, and of a bull, and of a bird of the night, and of a woman giving birth, and of a sighing man, and a thousand other voices more?"

"So it is," Vasudeva nodded, "all voices of the creatures are in its voice."

"And do you know," Siddhartha continued, "what word it speaks, when you succeed in hearing all of its ten thousand voices at once?"

Happily, Vasudeva's face was smiling, he bent over to Siddhartha and spoke the holy Om into his ear. And this had been the very thing which Siddhartha had also been hearing.

This scene with its imagery and symbol can affect the spirit or soul of the reader through relatedness /connectedness, beliefs/belief systems and if it does, at that particular moment, I would be led to believe that he has been touched by spirituality.

Thus literature, as Prof. Wickman says, is a vehicle of spirituality.


“Better to Reign in Hell than Serve in Heaven”:
A Study of Spiritual Defiance and Indomitable Will in Paradise Lost

Rajan Lal

A spirit may be defined as an animating or vitalizing essence or force that motivates or energises someone or something or a supernatural being without body. They may be identified as good and bad ones. Paradise Lost abounds in both types of spirits—God and His legions and Satan/Lucifer and his legions representing good and bad respectively. The maxim “Better to reign in Hell than serve in Heaven” comes from a monologue delivered by Satan in Book I of the epical poem the Paradise Lost composed by the belated Elizabethan-cum-Puritan English poet John Milton (1608-1674). When the epic begins, Satan with his legions of fallen angels have already been defeated by God and His legions and they have been cast into the depths of Tartarus, which is described as horrible, dark, fiery place full of pain and suffering. It is not the sort of place anyone in their right mind would want to rule.

The problem is, though, that these fallen angels were so deluded and full up on their own hubris that they honestly thought that they would win the war against God. Now, here, they are defeated and literally condemned to eternal damnation in hell. There is no escape that they know of. They are at their lowest point. Again, though they have already lost, Satan knows that he needs to keep these fallen angels on his side. When he speaks these famed-cum-fiery and immortal words, he is talking to his fallen angel Beelzebub. Throughout the poem, Satan’s talent is his rhetoric, exhibiting his spiritual revolt against God and his indomitable will, though pseudonymously; he can twist the truth to make even the brightest of people believe the most inane things. Thus, he knows that he needs to say something that will make Beelzebub and his associate cohorts think that this is some kind of their victory and not their defeat.

  


Spirituality and Literature: Some Reflections

Saurabh Agarwal

Spirituality and Literature are two threads of different colours that form the integral part of the fabric of humanity. Separating them and yet visualising a complete pattern will be difficult. But when one talks of spirituality the word religion appears as a conjoined twin with it. So, is the spirituality inconceivable without religion?   What constitutes spirituality in literature and what texts can be classified as spiritual literature? HarperCollins (San Francisco) has compiled a list of 100 Best Spiritual Books of the Century (20th). The list shows books like The Trial by Kafka, Chronicles of Narnia by C.S Lewis, The Plague by Camus, Wise Blood by Flannery O’Conner, The Power and Glory by Graham Greene,  Gandhi’s The Story of My Experiments with Truth,  The Gosepl of Ramakrishna Paramahansa,  An Autobiography of Yogi by Paramahansa Yoganada and Teachings of Ramana Maharshi. In the same list works of Tagore, Yeats and T.S. Eliot also appear. Some of the names do not bear direct relation to any religion per se or religious philosophy. So, what makes a text spiritual? Also, we have seen how scriptures of one section of society is considered blasphemous by another.

A text seemingly secular may have revelatory potential enough to send a person into a trance and transcends you to a higher plane.  As Leonard Cohen, the famous song writer, said, “There is a blaze of light in every word/ It doesn’t matter which you heard /Holy or the broken Hallelujah.” M.K. Gandhi said, “When doubts haunt me, when disappointment stares me in the face, and I see not one ray of hope on the horizon, I turn to Bhagwat Gita and find a verse to comfort me.” For Wordsworth flowers “flash upon that inward eye” which is “the bliss of solitude.”  But, according to me, the pinnacle of spirituality is as mentioned by Ramakrishna Paramahansa as “When, hearing the name of Hari or Rama once, you shed tears and your hair stands on end, then you may know for certain that you do not have to perform such devotions as the sandhya any more. Then only will you have a right to renounce rituals; or rather, rituals will drop away by themselves. Then it will be enough it you repeat only the name of Rama or Hari, or even simply Om." Continuing, he said, "The sandhya merges in the Gayatri, and the Gayatri merges in Om."


                                              Spirituality and Literature

                                                     Shipra Kulsrestha

The term spirituality has expanded over time. It can be understood as relating to or affecting the human spirit or soul as opposed to material or physical things. There are different connotations for the word ‘spirituality’. The poets, writers and playwrights have used it vividly in their work. “The Psalm of Life” by Henry Wadsworth Longfellow is the finest example of it. In this poem a young man is talking to the psalmist as the subtitle of this poem suggests: ‘What the heart of the young man said to the psalmist’. The young man says to the psalmist not to tell in the mournful way:

               Life is but an empty dream,
               For the soul is dead that slumbers,
               And things are not what they seem.

The young man does not agree with the psalmist when he says there is nothing in this life and life is only an empty dream. The psalmist says that soul is dead and things are not as they appear. The young man replies to the psalmist:

              Life is real, life is earnest,
              And the grave is not its goal;
            Dust thou art, to dust returnest
           Was not spoken of the soul.

That man says to the psalmist you  can not say that there is nothing  in this life and one day you have to die. He repudiates hedonic approach to life. He says life is full of meaning.  And there is a lot to do in this life.  It depends upon us. We should not think that one day we have to die, so there is no use of working. We should live a life full of achievements.

It is the body which perishes, not the soul. Soul is immortal. Only body is destroyed. The soul is always there which changes the body as we change the clothes. So we should not think that life is only to enjoy or to cry. There are many things more than it. We should work hard always. So that we can find ourselves farther than today. This is the difference between us and the beasts. The purpose of life should be to make a kind of progress that can be interpreted as spiritual improvement rather than as any kind of worldly success.  Our attitude towards life should be of Carpe diem.


This life is like a temporary tent as knights use for battlefield for a short time because the soul enters in this body for one birth and after this birth goes to take another birth. So, it is a cycle which continues. This is a stage or field for us where we are to play our acts. As the  actors change their dress, we should change this body. So, we should make full and most use of it. Our life should not be ‘like dumb driven cattle’ rather ‘Be a hero in the strife’. Our life should be full of action and optimism. Whatever the fate may be, we should be active, and try to pursue  and achieve our goal. We should work hard and wait as was said in the Gita also. Longfellow declines hedonic way of life and suggests to be active and hard working. This poem truly illustrates spiritual meaning of our life and shows us the right path to move ahead.